Skip to content

Group Theory in Psychology: Who Developed It and Its History

  • by Ricardo De Castro King
By Ricardo De Castro King · University lecturer for 16 years · Psique Académica
Written by Ricardo De Castro King, university lecturer for 16 yearsPublished

Definition

The scientific study of groups began in the early twentieth century in sociology and social psychology, and took shape with Kurt Lewin, who created "group dynamics" in the 1940s. It was later expanded by Wilfred Bion, from psychoanalysis, and by Enrique Pichon-Rivière with operative groups.

Thesis of these notes. Group dynamics did not begin as an HR technique or a corporate-workshop fad. It emerged where three streams met: the experimental social psychology of Kurt Lewin in the United States, the clinical experience of Wilfred Bion with therapeutic groups at the Tavistock Clinic in London, and the Latin American reworking of those sources by Enrique Pichon-Rivière, who founded the operative group in Argentina. Without that trajectory, the concepts we now take for granted —basic assumptions, ECRO, social climate, T-group, primary groups— read like loose labels, and you lose sight of the theoretical question behind each technique's birth.
Thread of the notes: Roots → Lewin → Bion and Pichon-Rivière → Institutionalization → Today.

1. Sociological and psychological roots of group study

Before there was a field with that name, the question of the group was already circulating in sociology and psychology in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. European sociology was concerned with how the social takes forms that exceed the individual, and academic psychology was looking for an object that could not be reduced to the isolated subject of the laboratory.

In the sociological tradition, Charles Horton Cooley introduced the notion of primary groups in Social Organization (1909) for intimate, face-to-face associations that are stable over time, such as the family, the peer group, or the neighborhood gang. What mattered about the category was not size but the kind of bond: the person's social self is formed in a primary group. Georg Simmel, for his part, worked in parallel on sociability as a pure form of interaction and on the structural properties of dyads and triads. Those two lines —Cooley on intimacy, Simmel on form— fed the idea that a group has properties irreducible to the sum of its members. Jacob Moreno's sociometry, contemporary with that work, supplied an instrument for mapping choices and rejections within a collective, and set the stage for the arrival of experimental psychology.

In psychology, the experimental lead arrived by a side road. Norman Triplett, in 1898, observed that cyclists performed better when racing alongside others than when riding alone, and designed an experiment with children winding fishing reels to demonstrate what he called social facilitation. Decades later, in 1913, Max Ringelmann found that the effort exerted in a rope-pulling task decreased as more people were added, and described what is now known as social loafing. Those two findings opened the central question Lewin would inherit: if the presence of others changes individual behavior, what are the laws of that change and how do you investigate them?

The social psychology of the 1920s and 1930s —Floyd Allport, William McDougall, Muzafer Sherif— began to treat the group as a unit of study. But a theoretical instrument capable of uniting the scattered findings and producing a research program was still missing. Kurt Lewin brought it from Berlin.

2. Lewin and group dynamics as an experimental field

Kurt Lewin arrived in the United States in 1933, fleeing the Nazi regime, carrying an unusual theoretical baggage for American psychology: the field theory he had developed in Berlin in dialogue with Gestalt psychology and topological mathematics. His underlying thesis was that behavior B is a function of the person P and the environment E —a formula usually written B = f(P, E)—, and that neither P nor E can be studied separately because behavior emerges from the whole field that both constitute.

Lewin applied that idea to the group with a decisive theoretical consequence: the group is better understood as a field with properties of its own than as a mere aggregate of individuals. This led him to design three lines of experimental work that became central to the discipline: the systematic comparison of leadership climates, the invention of the T-group as a training device, and the institutional consolidation of the field through the National Training Laboratories. Below I develop the first two lines, because the third is covered in the section on institutionalization.

2.1. The group climate experiments

In 1938–1939, Lewin, Ronald Lippitt, and Ralph White carried out the famous experiments with boys' clubs of ten- and eleven-year-olds in Iowa. They compared three leadership climates —autocratic, democratic, and laissez-faire— and measured productivity, aggression, cohesion, and satisfaction. The results are textbook material, but the detail is worth remembering:

  • In the autocratic climate, productivity was high while the leader was present but dropped as soon as he left, and a scapegoat pattern formed around one or two members.
  • In the democratic climate, productivity was somewhat lower but more stable, there was less aggression, and satisfaction was markedly higher.
  • In the laissez-faire climate, the group produced little, showed frustration, and no one took charge of the task.

What mattered to Lewin was not the ranking of the climates but the idea that the leader's style shapes the group field —that is, the structure of forces, valences, and barriers that organizes the behavior of the people present. The practical consequence, which he defended energetically, was that democratic leaders could be trained, and that this training was a lever for social change. That shift —from basic research to action research— marked the whole later trajectory of the field.

Analogy. If you think of the group as a fish tank, what Lewin showed is that it is not enough to look at each fish: what matters is the current, the temperature, the light, and the hiding places. Change the water and the fish's behavior changes even though you haven't touched a single one.

2.2. The invention of the T-group

Lewin's other big bet was to found, together with Leland Bradford and Ronald Lippitt, the National Training Laboratories (NTL) in Bethel, Maine, in 1947. There the T-group (training group) was born: a short format —two to three weeks— in which a small group met with a facilitator to observe its own behavior here and now, with no explicit task, in order to learn from the process the group itself generated. Out of that experience came training in observation and feedback skills, the reading of group climate, and attention to informal roles.

The T-group branched in directions Lewin did not live to see: the encounter groups of the 1960s, the organizational development of Douglas McGregor, Rensis Likert, and Chris Argyris, and the huge industry of corporate workshops. Dorwin Cartwright and Alvin Zander edited the field's canonical text, Group Dynamics: Research and Theory, which synthesized that legacy and became required reading in American universities for decades.

Lewin "invented groups." No. Lewin did not invent groups, nor did he invent the study of the group. What he did was give it a theoretical status —the field— and an experimental program —climate, training— that made it possible to investigate the group as a unit irreducible to the sum of individuals.

3. Contributions of Wilfred Bion and Enrique Pichon-Rivière

If the Lewinian current came from experimental social psychology, the contributions that finally gave the field its clinical depth came from psychoanalysis. Two figures concentrate that transformation: Wilfred Bion in London and Enrique Pichon-Rivière in Buenos Aires. Both owe a debt to the Tavistock, both formulated a vocabulary of their own, and both left behind a format with its own grammar. It is worth telling them apart, because they are often confused.

3.1. Wilfred Bion and basic assumptions

Bion was a Kleinian psychoanalyst who worked at the Tavistock Clinic with groups of traumatized soldiers during World War II. Faced with the Tavistock's classic setup —individual therapy on the couch—, Bion found himself running sessions where several patients were together and the usual frame fell apart. He began to notice that, besides the properly therapeutic work, the group entered states that blocked the work and suspended it.

What he described, in Experiences in Groups (1961), were three basic assumptions, which coexist and take turns with one another:

  1. Dependency (baD): the group organizes around the hope that the leader, or an idealized member, will provide salvation. Knowledge from the outside is devalued and the group expects to be fed.
  2. Fight-flight (baF): the group coheres around an external enemy —real or imagined— and the task is subordinated to fighting or fleeing. The key point is that aggression organizes the group rather than scattering it.
  3. Pairing (baP): the group places its hope in a couple within the group who will produce a redemptive solution, without that hope ever materializing.

These states are not pathological in themselves: they are defensive movements of the group as a whole in the face of the anxiety the task arouses. The work group —the mature mode of the group, centered on the task— coexists with them and needs to be sustained by a conductor able to read and point out those movements. Later, authors such as Pierre Turquet, Earl Hopper, and W. Gordon Lawrence extended the model with additional assumptions such as oneness and incohesion (aggregation/massification), but the original trio remains the most cited.

Bion deals with business dynamics. No. Bion wrote about therapeutic groups at the Tavistock Clinic, in a clinical setting, in the postwar period. His categories were later taken up by the Tavistock Institute for the study of organizations, but that is a derived use, not the origin of the concept.

3.2. Pichon-Rivière and the operative group

Pichon-Rivière trained as a psychoanalyst in Buenos Aires, came into contact with Kleinian work and then with the Tavistock, and from that crossing came his most lasting creation: the operative group. Unlike Bion's format —clinical, centered on unconscious conflict—, Pichon-Rivière's operative group was conceived from the start as a device for training and for learning the task. It was born in Argentine neuropsychiatric hospitals and in the first schools of psychology and social work.

The core concepts of the Pichonian approach are four:

  • ECRO (Conceptual, Referential, and Operative Scheme): the set of theories, readings, and prior experiences each member brings to the group and that organizes how they read the task. Learning to modify one's own ECRO is the goal of the format.
  • Spokesperson (portavoz): the member who says what the group does not dare —or cannot— say. They do not speak only for themselves; they speak on behalf of the group. The coordinator's task includes listening to the spokesperson as a way into the group as a whole.
  • Verticality and horizontality of distress: the group's illness or conflict has a horizontal dimension (what is happening now, in the here and now of the session) and a vertical dimension (what repeats from the history of the group, of institutions, of the people). The two dimensions intertwine and each needs the other to be thought through.
  • Group as body: the group works as an organism with its own anxiety, defenses, and ways of working through. The body metaphor is not decorative: it guides clinical listening.

The operative group became, and remains, a central tool in the training of psychologists, social workers, community health teams, and teachers in Argentina, Brazil, Uruguay, Chile, and Mexico. In Argentina it had a strong institutional core in the Centro Pichon-Rivière and in hospital services in Buenos Aires and La Plata. An early decision —that the group is not a therapeutic luxury but a training tool— guided that expansion and set it apart from other European clinical traditions.

Pichon-Rivière is just an epigone of European psychoanalysis with no territory of his own. No. What is specific to Pichon-Rivière is that he built a device of his own —the operative group—, with a vocabulary of his own —ECRO, spokesperson, task, verticality—, designed for a context —the public hospital, the training of professionals— that European psychoanalysis had not addressed.
To remember

Lewin: the group as a field. B = f(P, E).

Bion: the group alternates between work and three basic assumptions (dependency, fight-flight, pairing).

Pichon-Rivière: the operative group works the task by modifying ECRO and reading the spokesperson.

4. Institutionalization of the field

During the 1940s and 1950s, the field of group dynamics became institutionalized through several parallel channels: university laboratories, private training centers, professional associations, clinical settings, and application to the world of work. That institutionalization left traces worth recognizing, because they still organize the practices you will run into.

4.1. Laboratories and research centers

The Research Center for Group Dynamics was founded at MIT in 1945 by Lewin, and later moved to the University of Michigan, where Dorwin Cartwright and Alvin Zander turned it into the core producer of the Handbook of Group Dynamics and of the collective volumes that bear that name. In parallel, the Tavistock Institute of Human Relations —created in London in 1947— took in the work of Bion and his colleagues, and moved toward the group relations conferences model that A.K. Rice brought to the United States. Those two poles —Michigan and Tavistock— fed most of the Anglo-American academic research on groups for decades.

4.2. Group clinical work in Latin America

In Latin America, group dynamics was institutionalized by very different routes from the North American ones. Pichon-Rivière and his collaborators —especially José Bleger, Hernán Kesselman, and Eduardo Pavlovsky— tied group clinical work to hospital services and to the training of professional teams. That current spread to Brazil through the São Paulo school, to Uruguay, and to Chile under and after the dictatorship, where the operative group was used as a working device with mental health and human rights teams.

An early decision weighs on that institutionalization: that the group is not a therapeutic luxury but a training tool. That orientation explains why today you find it as a routine working tool in community health teams, in social work schools, and in popular education settings. Transmission happened through formal routes —specialization programs, residencies— and informal ones —peer supervision, case conferences—, and that double route gave it a durability the Anglo-American literature rarely records.

4.3. Organizational development and training

In the Anglo world, Lewin's legacy crossed with the organizational development (OD) movement of McGregor, Likert, and Argyris, and with the spread of Carl Rogers's encounter groups. The T-group left the laboratory and entered companies. That expansion had two consequences worth keeping in mind: on one hand, it democratized the practice and made it accessible to wide audiences; on the other, it separated the device from its theoretical base and made it open to instrumental uses that had little to do with Lewin. The risk, still current, is that the device becomes a technique of seduction with no reading of the field.

The table below summarizes the axes along which the field became institutionalized:

Axis of institutionalization Characteristic institution or format Theoretical reading
Academic research Research Center for Group Dynamics (MIT, later Michigan); Tavistock Institute Field, climate, basic assumptions
Professional training National Training Laboratories (NTL); social work schools T-group, feedback, observation
Group clinical work Tavistock Clinic; hospital services in Argentina, Brazil, Uruguay Work group and basic assumptions
Team training Centro Pichon-Rivière; public health schools Operative group, ECRO, spokesperson
Organizational development Consulting firms, private universities Team, participative leadership, OD

5. Group dynamics today

The field has changed quite a bit in recent decades. It helps to distinguish five lines along which the discipline now moves, so you know where to place the references you come across.

5.1. Disciplinary fragmentation

Group dynamics stopped being a unified field and split among social psychology —which in recent decades favored studies of individuation and networks—, organizational studies —focused on work teams, effectiveness, and shared cognition—, group clinical work —holed up in specific settings and off the central stage—, and education —where cooperative learning and the classroom as a group came back up for debate—. That fragmentation has a pedagogical consequence: if you train in only one of those traditions, your picture of the field will be partial. That is why it is worth reading Lewin, Bion, and Pichon-Rivière up front, even if you later specialize in just one.

5.2. Continued vitality of the operative group

In Argentina, Brazil, and Uruguay, group clinical work and training through the operative group remain active. Centers such as the Pichon-Rivière in Buenos Aires, academic groups in São Paulo and Porto Alegre, and training programs in public health services sustain a living transmission of Pichon-Rivière's concepts. That tradition is less internationalized than Bion's or Lewin's, which is why it is often missing from English-language textbooks —far from being a minor point, that makes it more valuable for you to know it from the primary source.

5.3. New formats and old questions

In applied settings, formats have appeared that reformulate the old questions: self-organizing work teams, communities of practice, peer learning groups, clinical intervision formats, co-parenting groups in mental health. Those formats share the question of how people learn in a group, which was already in Lewin and in Pichon-Rivière. What is new is the medium (digital platforms, hybrid modes) rather than the question.

5.4. Critique and vigilance

The field has also received relevant criticism —encounter groups as manipulation techniques, the uncritical export of Anglo models to non-Anglo contexts, the illusion that the group format alone solves institutional problems—. Those critiques are as much a part of the field as its classic texts, and it helps to read them as internal vigilance. A good way to start reading the field is to alternate a canonical text with a contemporary critique of that text.

Recommended reading to continue. If you are just starting, read in this order: Bion's Experiences in Groups (1961), a chapter by Cartwright and Zander for the classic synthesis, and a text by Pichon-Rivière on ECRO. With that minimal triangle you can read the concepts as tools, not as labels.

5.5. Case to think about: a misquoted exam answer

Case. On a social psychology midterm, a student writes: "Lewin invented the T-group to improve business productivity, and Bion applied basic assumptions to coaching." The question is: what do you correct, and why?
What goes wrong. (a) Lewin did not "invent" groups, nor did he create the T-group as a business technique: he created it as an experimental and training device, tied to research on climate and to a program of social change. (b) Bion did not apply basic assumptions to coaching: he described them in therapeutic groups at the Tavistock, in a clinical setting, in the postwar period. Later use in organizations is derived, not original.
How to think about it. The sentence confuses origin with later use. When a concept travels, you have to distinguish the context where it was born from the context where it is applied today. Otherwise the origin becomes invisible, the concept seems to have existed "forever," and you lose the chance to discuss what it was designed for.

5.6. Questions for studying these notes

Why did Lewin need a field theory to investigate groups?

Because the question that interested him was how the environment changes behavior, and a person's "environment" is, in part, the group they belong to. Without a field theory, he had no way to describe the group as a whole or to investigate the relationship between the forces of the field and individual behavior.

What is the difference between a basic assumption and an individual emotion?

A basic assumption is a disposition of the group as a whole: it is the emotional climate that organizes the behavior of the people present at a given moment. An individual emotion is each member's own experience. The key point is that the basic assumption cannot be reduced to the sum of individual emotions: it is an emergent property of the group field.

What does the concept of ECRO add that is not already in Lewin's concept of field?

ECRO adds the historical and operative dimension: each member brings a scheme formed over their biography and professional training, and that scheme is modified —or not— by work in the group. Field theory describes the current structure of forces; ECRO describes the sediment each person brings into play.

Why does the institutionalization of the field matter for practice?

Because the institutions where the formats were developed —public hospitals, university laboratories, social work schools— shape which kinds of groups became possible. If you know that history, you can read current practices along with their tensions instead of receiving them as if they were neutral.

Full route: Roots (Cooley, Triplett, Ringelmann, Moreno) → Lewin (field, climate, T-group, NTL) → Bion (basic assumptions at the Tavistock) and Pichon-Rivière (operative group, ECRO, spokesperson, in Argentina) → Institutionalization (Michigan, NTL, Tavistock, Argentine hospitals, social work schools, OD) → Today (disciplinary fragmentation, vitality of the operative group in Latin America, new formats, internal critique).

To practice on your own, explore the tests and practice exams section.

Keep reading

  • Intergroup relations: how the us and the them are constituted when two or more groups come into contact.
  • Group productivity and collective action: how action is decided (and postponed) in a group, and why.
  • Social influence in collectives: how norms, opinions, and climates are transmitted within a group.

Frequently asked questions

Who developed group theory in psychology?

Kurt Lewin, who created "group dynamics" in the 1940s and the Research Center for Group Dynamics (1945). Other key contributions came from Jacob Moreno (sociometry), Wilfred Bion, and Enrique Pichon-Rivière. In mathematics, "group theory" is something else entirely: it was developed by Évariste Galois in the nineteenth century.

What is group theory in social psychology?

The study of how groups form and function and how they influence their members: norms, roles, status, cohesion, leadership, and conflict.

Which authors have studied groups?

Kurt Lewin, Jacob Moreno, Muzafer Sherif (norms and intergroup conflict), Solomon Asch (conformity), Henri Tajfel (social identity), Wilfred Bion, and Enrique Pichon-Rivière.

What is group dynamics?

Kurt Lewin's term for the forces that operate within a group and make it change: communication, cohesion, leadership, and decision making.

PsiqueAcadémica · Note M83-1 · Historical background of group study · Group dynamics

To practice on your own, explore the tests and practice exams section.

  • Intergroup relations
  • Group productivity and collective action
  • Social influence in collectives